Board Thread:Wiki discussion/@comment-5635930-20141122144518/@comment-4196050-20141122172245

As what I have reiterated multiple times, we only restrict pages on our mainspace. The userspace (User:EditorName/PageName) has no restrictions. There is absolutely no differences between a mainspace page and a userspace page in terms of who can view and edit the page.

It would be hard to set qualitative standards instead of quantitative. I might consider a 4K group with a certain history appropriate for a mainspace page, while another administrator might not think the page is worthy of one. Setting quantitative measurements allows for consistency across all pages of the wikia and minimizes the chances of editors/administrators being accused of favoratory actions towards certain pages and not others.

What needs to be done is create an appeals system for pages (I think the ROBLOX Wikia already has one -though it is never used). If a user feels like a page is notable due to its history but does not meet the notability policies, then that user can appeal to the administrators and let them (possibly majority vote from all active admins?) decide whether a page should be allowed on the mainspace.

Unfortunately, not a lot of administrators are on during the school year. Most (if not all) of us are high school or college students and have obligations outside of the ROBLOX Wikia to complete first. We are the most active during the summer, when we experience the highest amount of wiki activity from editors (the wiki's editor demographics is school-aged children and teens and tend to experience lower editor activity during the school year).